The MCI reasons its own action by saying it really wants to enhance the standard of health Education in India.
There cannot be a second opinion that the grade of health education in India is far from decent. There is an urgent requirement to reevaluate the criteria, methodology and content of health education in India.
Selecting the very best students for training may be one necessity to achieve standards. Nonetheless, it remains a small step in achieving quality training. Regrettably for another professional education in India the selection process for entry is made to appear as the sole determinant of quality. The infrastructure of this institution, the quality of teachers, the availability of clinical material, the methodology, research potential and uniformity of standards throughout the united states does not draw attention and debate. That is regrettable considering the huge change in the standards of education from many parts of the country and between institutions within the states.
Our health care education has to be assessed with respect to its own content and relevance. The MBBS course is called’medical education’ in India where as it is called Medical Training all over the world. There is a sea of difference between the word’education’ and’training’. The Indian medical education involves analyzing volumes and quantities of novels and getting theoretical comprehension using very less technical training. Like any other education in India, medical instruction doesn’t help the student to grow clinic oriented thinking and clinical treatment modalities. Students competed in the UK or US are better equipped to face an individual in a clinic or emergency room even if they might not have read many novels such as their Indian counterparts.
The figures from great britain are meant for medical ราชภัฏสวนสุนันทา researchers in britain. The American medical novels demonstrate that the American hospital environment and also the American patients. For instance the management of injury care is presented in American Colleges with the American Idol service and emergency room scenario from the mind. That really isn’t the situation in our nation. Our students browse the American and British medical textbooks. This might be one explanation why they all would like to go to Britain and America!
They aren’t trained to go to a Indian village and see someone in a Main Health Center. They do not see that much about malaria and skin ailments that are therefore typical in our nation. They neither have novels which give them comprehensive knowledge in regards to the Indian medical condition nor get the correct training for Indian clinical practice. We want more research about Indian epidemiology and instruction materials based on this.
We hear people talking about training our graduates to’international standards’. They insist that our professionals need to have the ability to go to any nation in the world and live. The percentage of Indian medical graduates moving abroad is likely to be less than one percentage. If we be designing our healthcare curriculum to help those less than 1 percent to reach their personal goals? No nation in the world needs to aim its education programs to coach their own students to move abroad. We are in need of doctors to serve our taxpayers. We need large quantities of doctors to serve in rural India. It is mad to talk about’international standards’ if what we want is just a real’Indian norm’.
Still another major handicap for the Indian student is that he has to master medicine in a foreign language. The ideal way to learn science or Medicine is always to learn in one’s mother tongue. That is likely to produce the learning process interesting and help develop research believing. Every European, whether German, French or Russian studies Medication in their mother tongue. China, Japan and even a small country like Thailand provide medical instruction into their mother tongue. It’s a possibility. It is practical. The sole resistance would be which our students cannot go abroad and work. That’s a lame explanation. First of all let the health care graduates not go to overseas all, even leaving our country. Graduates of those states should they wish to proceed abroad they must learn English, French or German or whatever language through a brief course. Our students should also accomplish that. Our students may study English as second language in school. We may even add English language instruction in the Medical curriculum as an option. Therefore there cannot be any excuses for not only teaching Medication within their respective mother tongues in most of the states.
When so much has to be achieved in order to improve the grade of health training in India projecting common entrance examination for entering Medical education as the panacea for these problems will soon be counterproductive.
The selection of candidates into the MBBS course is a significant step in improving the standard of education. The selection procedure has to be regularized. The private clinical institutions and also the so called’regarded as universities’ have a free run from the selection. A student who has failed in the matriculation examination and passed out in the 2nd attempt can also purchase a chair in these types of institutions. Most of the students entering a few of these institutions have secured more than ten marks than the lowest mark of a student entering the government institution in reserved category. There’s not any barrier of minimum marks for inputting many of the private institutions. There’s absolutely not any competitive test for entry. The single criterion will be money. The seats can be purchased in open auction. This can be of grave concern whenever you talk about keeping up the standard of health education. We need to regularize the decision procedure, entrance modalities and fee arrangement of the private institutions to reach standards. The MCI appears to ben’t bothered about these problems for unknown reasons.
The Tamil Nadu experience has clearly shown the injuries of their entrance examinations. Abolition of entry examination has raised the proportion of rural students entering professional classes from 28% to 64 percent. Re introduction of entry examination will undo this and also harm the rural students. School instruction has already been a big enterprise. Abolition of entrance examination helped not merely the rural students and students from government high schools to go into professional colleges. If CET has been introduced the private schools that offer training to get entrance examination along with the normal program will create festive by enhancing their business. It centres for entry exam will flourish in cities and also the rich and urban learners can get undue benefit. The rural students will soon be marginalized.
The reason why the IITs, National Law Schools and Central Government Medical institutions remain the den of the students from urban legends is that the entrance examination to all these institutions are centered on CBSE syllabus. Again looking at Tamil Nadu adventure, an individual may observe that out from both and a quarter lakh students analyzing twelfth standard approximately five lakh are condition syllabus students, about one 5 lakh are from matriculation syllabus. The CET will be determined by the CBSE syllabus that’s more voluminous compared to different syllabuses. This will take advantage of a microscopic minority and also exclude more and more poor and also the distance by the rural side.